A court-appointed psychologist approaches Rush regarding a client, Sean, a troubled 17-year-old boy who's been lost in the foster care system since he witnessed the murder of his mother, Rebecca, 14 years ago.
DNA evidence reveals the wrong man was imprisoned for the 1986 murder of 15-year-old Eve Kendall. Rush and Valens reopen the case and discover that the teen was desired by several men, younger and older.
After new evidence clears an accused murderer during his triple homicide trial, the detectives talk to the murdered busboy's brother. Then they interview a waitress and a local thug. Both reportedly argued with one of the murder victims that night.
A 60-year reunion of World War II female factory workers stirs up memories of a mysterious death. A friend of the deceased confides to Rush that the death is not what it appears to be and begs her to dig deeper into the case.